The Vitality Global Health and Productivity Index: In Conversation with RAND Europe

The Vitality Global Health and Productivity Index, developed with RAND Europe, draws on data from 9,000+ employees across five countries. It estimates that poor workforce health costs these economies $3.34 trillion.

 

The research looks beyond absence alone to understand how physical health, mental wellbeing, lifestyle behaviours and workplace conditions combine to influence workforce productivity.

 

In this Q&A, Ben Moss, Senior Research Leader at RAND Europe, explains what is driving productivity loss, why presenteeism matters more than absence, and what employers and policymakers can do to act earlier.

 

Q: What does Vitality’s data allow RAND Europe to understand about workforce health that other datasets cannot?

 

This dataset is distinctive because it does not look at health in isolation. It brings together employees’ physical health, mental wellbeing, lifestyle behaviours, working conditions and productivity in one place, for 10,000 employees across five countries. It does this using a tried, tested and consistent framework. That means we can look not just at whether people are unwell, but how different risks combine and what that means for key work-health outcomes. This survey allows us to connect those dots.

 

It also builds on nearly a decade of work that RAND Europe supported with Vitality as part of Britain’s Healthiest Workplace, collecting this kind of data for hundreds of employers. That means the measurement tools and the modelling approach linking health to productivity have been developed and tested over many years, rather than being built from scratch for a one-off study. In that sense, the data is unusually robust and reliable for this kind of research.

 

The findings show very clearly and reliably that health-related productivity loss is not being driven by one issue alone. Mental wellbeing, physical health burden, lifestyle risk and work strain all interact. The dataset also lets us see how much of the productivity cost sits in presenteeism rather than absence (the majority), which is often much harder for employers to measure.

 

For an independent research organisation like RAND Europe, this kind of evidence is especially valuable because it enables us to move beyond general statements about workplace wellbeing and say something specific about what is driving productivity loss, where the biggest risks sit and what kinds of responses are most likely to make a difference.

 

Q: Poor workforce health costs the five economies studied an estimated $3.34 trillion. What needs to change in how governments and employers respond to it?

 

A key message from the research is that poor workforce health should no longer be seen as a peripheral issue. The scale of the economic cost demonstrated in the report shows that this is a productivity issue, a workforce issue and, in many countries, an economic participation issue as well.

 

For employers, the big shift is from reacting to ill-health once it becomes visible to identifying risk earlier and acting sooner. That means measuring what actually drives productivity loss, especially presenteeism, using workforce data more effectively and enabling managers to provide support earlier in the process in a way that is tailored to specific employee needs. This is about moving away from generic wellbeing offers towards more targeted support.

 

It also means paying much closer attention to work design and to the conditions of work itself. Our findings show that work strain, manager support, role clarity, the ability to recover and, more broadly, how work is designed are all closely linked to productivity outcomes.

 

For governments, the opportunity is to create the conditions that make prevention easier. That includes better access to timely support, clearer work-health pathways and incentives for employers to invest in healthier work and earlier intervention. However, what needs to change won’t look the same everywhere, because the five countries in this research have very different policy landscapes and health systems.

 

The challenge in the UK or Germany, for example, is different from that in the US, where there is no NHS or social insurance model providing a broad universal foundation. But across all five countries, the strongest systems are not simply those that protect people once they are already unwell, but those that make prevention easier.

 

Q: Around 85% of the productivity loss comes from presenteeism rather than absence. Are current workplace policies measuring the wrong things?

 

In many cases, yes - or at least they are measuring the easier thing rather than the more important one. Most employers have reasonably mature systems for tracking absence and collecting associated data, but much less capability to identify when people are at work and not functioning well because of poor health. Our research suggests that is exactly where most of the productivity loss actually sits.

 

One of the challenges is that “presenteeism” is often treated as a single category when it really includes quite different employee experiences. In the report, we distinguish between workers who are present in a way that is reasonably functional - for example someone working with a minor illness (pragmatic presence), or returning in a supported way as part of recovery (therapeutic presence) - versus workers whose presence is genuinely dysfunctional, where they are too unwell to perform properly and may be making their condition worse by staying at work (True Presenteeism). Those are very different situations, but they are often lumped together under the same label, which makes both the data and the supportive response less meaningful.

 

The implication is that employers need better ways of understanding not just whether someone is absent or present, but what kind of presence they are seeing and what support is actually needed. Too often, the response is generic when the reality is much more specific. If employers can get better at recognising that difference, they will be in a much stronger position to support recovery, protect productivity and intervene earlier before problems escalate.

 

Q: 65% of workers experience psychological distress, but only 22% have a formal diagnosis. What does this tell us about the need for earlier intervention?

 

The most important finding, in my view, is the 65%. It tells us that a very large share of the global workforce is experiencing some level of psychological strain, and that this is now a mainstream feature of working life, not a marginal issue affecting a small group of people.

 

Important to note, however, that these figures do not mean all of that distress should, or ever would, lead to a formal diagnosis. Many people will experience periods of strain, stress, fatigue or anxiety that are real and important, but do not meet the threshold for a clinical condition. So I would be cautious about framing this simply as a “diagnosis gap” that needs to be closed.

 

What it does tell us very clearly, though, is that employers and policymakers cannot afford to wait until people become clinically unwell before acting. Our data shows that workers in the high mental wellbeing risk group lose 104.9 productive days per year on average (30.3 days more than the ‘no mental health risk group).

 

So the real implication is the need for earlier support, healthier work design, better line manager capability and clearer pathways to help when people begin to struggle. If we want to keep people healthy and in work, and avoid the longer-term costs of absence, attrition and economic inactivity, then intervention must happen well before crisis point.

 

Q: The workers most at risk often have the least access to support. How can governments and employers prevent workforce health inequalities from widening?

 

The first step is to recognise that workforce health inequalities are not accidental. In our data, the groups carrying the heaviest burden are often lower-income workers, shift workers, those with long-term conditions and, in some countries, younger workers as well. They are also more likely to report lower levels of support, or greater difficulty accessing what is available in practice.

 

For employers, that means moving away from a one-size-fits-all wellbeing offer. The most effective response is likely to be more targeted: understanding which groups in the workforce are under the greatest pressure, what kinds of barriers they face and whether existing support is actually reaching them. In some cases, that may mean redesigning communications, improving manager capability or making support easier to access for workers who are time-poor, deskless or less visible.

 

It may also mean thinking more seriously about extending health insurance and other forms of support to parts of the workforce that have traditionally had less access. In the UK, for example, only around 20% of workers report access to employer-provided health insurance. If that level were to rise meaningfully over time, especially among groups with the least support now, it could make a real difference to earlier access and prevention.

 

For governments, the opportunity is to create conditions that make that kind of employer investment more likely. That could mean stronger support for early intervention, better integration between health and work systems and incentives that help employers, especially smaller ones, invest in prevention. The UK’s Keep Britain Working agenda is a useful example. Faced with a health-related economic inactivity crisis, the response is not only about urging employers to do more, but about developing practical tools and standards to help them act - including work on an employer wellbeing support standard and a workplace health support offer alongside it. If the goal is to keep more people healthy and in work, then both employers and policymakers must focus not only on average outcomes, but on who is being left behind.

 

Q: The research shows that workplace conditions, including manager support, work strain and concerns about AI, directly affect productivity. Does this challenge the idea that wellbeing is primarily an individual responsibility?

 

I would say yes, very clearly. I’ve never believed workforce health and wellbeing is primarily an individual responsibility. Of course, individuals make choices and have agency, but employers create the conditions (physical, cultural) in which those choices are made and in which people either thrive or struggle.

 

One of the clearest findings from this research is that productivity is shaped not only by someone’s underlying health, but by the environment they are working in. Work strain, manager support, role clarity, workload, working hours and the ability to recover all have measurable links to health-related productivity loss. That means wellbeing is not just about whether an individual is resilient enough or motivated enough – it’s also about how work is designed and how people are managed, underpinned by culture.

 

Many employers nowadays understand that, but I do think this is an important reminder to them. Duty of care cannot be outsourced to employees through a menu of wellbeing benefits or an expectation that people should manage their own health in their own time. The most effective employers will be those that combine support for individual health with healthier work design, stronger management capability and a culture that makes it easier for people to make good choices and seek help early.

 

Q: If you could recommend three actions to policymakers, what would make the greatest difference to workforce health and productivity over the next decade?

 

First, I would prioritise prevention and early intervention over reactive responses. Across all five countries, the evidence suggests that systems are often better at protecting or treating people once they are already unwell than at stopping them reaching that point in the first place. Policymakers can help shift that by making it easier for employers to invest in prevention, timely access and healthier work, particularly for SMEs that may lack the capacity or infrastructure to do this alone.

 

Second, I would encourage a more tailored rather than generic approach to workforce health. The data shows very clearly that need is not evenly distributed. Younger workers, lower-income workers, shift workers and those with long-term conditions often face very different pressures. So, the most effective policies are likely to be those that help employers better understand their own workforce and target support accordingly, rather than assuming that one model of provision will work for everyone.

 

Third, I would focus on joining up national health policy and employer health and wellbeing policy much more deliberately. One of the clearest messages from this research is that people do not experience their health and their working life separately, but systems often still treat them that way. If policymakers want to reduce productivity loss, economic inactivity and longer-term welfare pressures, they need clearer work-health pathways, better integration between services and stronger incentives for earlier support before people fall out of work.

 

Q: What finding from the research surprised you most, and why?

 

What surprised me most was the scale of the productivity impact associated with AI-related concern. AI is often discussed as a future opportunity or a future threat, but what this research shows is that it is already having a measurable effect on health and productivity in the present.

 

In our analysis, workers with high AI-related concern lose an additional 27.6 productive days per year relative to those with no identified concern. What is particularly striking is that this is not mainly about fear of redundancy. The stronger signal in the data is technology stress: the strain created when new tools are introduced quickly, with unclear expectations, limited training or not enough worker input.

 

This suggests AI’s productivity problem is not only a technology issue, but a management and implementation issue. The employers most likely to benefit from AI will therefore not be those who adopt it fastest, but those that introduce it in a way that supports people, reduces stress and builds confidence rather than friction.